Inconvenient Kyoto Truths
Posted on | February 8, 2007 |
A good article from George Will at Newsweek.
Inconvenient Kyoto Truths
Was life better when a sheet of ice a mile thick covered Chicago? Was it worse when Greenland was so warm that Vikings farmed there?By George F. Will
NewsweekFeb. 12, 2007 issue - Enough already. It is time to call some bluffs. John Kerry says that one reason America has become an “international pariah” is President Bush’s decision to “walk away from global warming.” Kerry’s accusation is opaque, but it implies the usual complaint that Bush is insufficiently enthusiastic about the Kyoto Protocol’s binding caps on emissions of greenhouse gases. Many senators and other experts in climate science say we must “do something” about global warming. Barack Obama says “the world” is watching to see “what action we take.”
Fine. President Bush should give the world something amusing to watch. He should demand that the Senate vote on the protocol.
Climate Cassandras say the facts are clear and the case is closed. (Sen. Barbara Boxer: “We’re not going to take a lot of time debating this anymore.”) The consensus catechism about global warming has six tenets: 1. Global warming is happening. 2. It is our (humanity’s, but especially America’s) fault. 3. It will continue unless we mend our ways. 4. If it continues we are in grave danger. 5. We know how to slow or even reverse the warming. 6. The benefits from doing that will far exceed the costs.
Only the first tenet is clearly true, and only in the sense that the Earth warmed about 0.7 degrees Celsius in the 20th century. We do not know the extent to which human activity caused this. The activity is economic growth, the wealth-creation that makes possible improved well-being—better nutrition, medicine, education, etc. How much reduction of such social goods are we willing to accept by slowing economic activity in order to (try to) regulate the planet’s climate?
Related posts:
- What’s Up, Doc? Global Warming: The Up-Side I have a new favorite author! Doc shows an insite (and an incite) into the idiot...
- www.predictweather.com -|- Global Warming www.predictweather.com -|- Global Warming Another great resource on the perceived threat of global warming. Wisdom ...
- USATODAY.com - The debate’s over: Globe is warming It’s interesting how this is all explained as fact. The truth is, the debate is not over. There is a...
- The Threat of Socia(Environmenta)lism Socialism and environmentalism have crashed together to form a new creature I like to call socia(environmenta)lism. It's roots lay deep...
- Obesity contributes to global warming: study Here’s my take: Fat people cause global warming…and skinny people cause global warming. As the article below explains, fat people...
Comments
Leave a Reply
